Independent advisersAdvisory service

Selection advisory

Running the evaluation: turning a long list into a shortlist, scripting the demonstrations so every vendor answers the same questions, and documenting why the decision went the way it did.

4 firms state it5 things to ask forReviewed September 2026

Build the requirements first

01When you need it

When nobody internally has selected a system before, or when the committee cannot agree and needs the argument put on paper rather than settled by whoever is most senior in the room.

Stackmark research · editorial, not sourced from any firm

02What to ask for

Put these in the engagement letter rather than the kick-off meeting. Each one is a thing that is awkward to ask for later and cheap to ask for now.

  1. 01

    A written statement that the adviser takes no fee, referral or margin from any vendor or reseller, for this engagement or any other.

  2. 02

    The evaluation criteria and their weights, agreed by you before any vendor is scored.

  3. 03

    Demonstration scripts built from your own transactions, not the vendor’s demo data.

  4. 04

    A decision paper naming the runners-up and why each fell away, so a successor can audit the choice.

  5. 05

    Named people, with the hours they will personally spend, not a firm-level promise.

03How it is priced

Usually a fixed fee for the selection, sometimes a day rate with a capped total. Fees contingent on a system being chosen, or on the licence value, are a conflict — the adviser then earns more from a bigger deal.

Stackmark publishes no day rates. Nobody in this market posts them, an adviser’s rate varies more by who is assigned than by the firm, and a range we made up would be exactly the invented figure we refuse to print for licences. Ask two firms for a fixed fee on the same written scope; the comparison is the number you actually need.

04Firms that state this service

Firms whose own site names this work, alphabetical. A listing is a documented claim by the firm, not a recommendation by us, and there is no tier, rating or paid placement anywhere on this page.

  • ERP Advisors Group

    Does not state independence

    Its own wording: “Needs Assessment”, “ERP Selection”, “ERP Implementation”

    Also states implementation oversight, requirements gathering

  • Lumenia Consulting

    States vendor independence

    Its own wording: “ERP Selection”, “ERP Strategy & Planning”, “ERP Implementation”, “Business Process Transformation”

    Also states change management, erp audits and expert review, implementation oversight, programme recovery, requirements gathering

  • Third Stage Consulting Group

    States vendor independence

    Its own wording: “ERP Selection & Implementation”, “ERP Project Recovery”, “Expert Witness Services”, “Digital Transformation”

    Also states change management, erp audits and expert review, implementation oversight, programme recovery

  • Ultra Consultants

    States vendor independence

    Its own wording: “ERP Technology Selection”, “ERP Implementation”, “ERP Recovery”, “Organizational Change Management”

    Also states change management, implementation oversight, programme recovery

A firm we have missed, or one listed wrongly? Suggest a correction. It opens a public issue, prefilled with what we publish today.

05Sources

The page on each firm’s own site that names the service, and the date we read it. The reading of those pages — which of our seven services a firm’s wording maps to — is Stackmark’s, which is why the firm’s own words are printed above.

  1. [1]Needs Assessment | ERP Advisors Group Serviceshttps://www.erpadvisorsgroup.com/services · retrieved 2026-09-07
  2. [2]ERP & Digital Consulting Services | Lumenia Consulting: Independent ERP Consultantshttps://www.lumeniaconsulting.com/services · retrieved 2026-09-07
  3. [3]Services : Independent Guidance. Proven Results.https://www.thirdstageconsulting.com/services/ · retrieved 2026-09-07
  4. [4]Independent ERP Consultants | ERP Consulting | Ultrahttps://www.ultraconsultants.com/erp-consulting-services/ · retrieved 2026-09-07